Library of Congress staff marked Halloween with a presentation on some of the collection's most haunting finds, from fraudulent 19th-century spirit photographs to a 200-year-old ghost legend and the early days of horror comics.

In the Prints and Photographs Division, archivist Maggie McCready explained that spirit photography in the 19th century reflected how grief and loss fueled a spiritualism phase in the 1850s and 1860s. The massive loss of life during the Civil War, combined with Victorian anxiety about death, led to a desire to connect with deceased loved ones.

Photographers such as William H. Mumler claimed to show spirits in their images, but the effect came from old glass plate negatives that left a ghostly image behind on the new photograph. Scandal struck when one of the "spirits" in a Mumler photo turned out to be alive, and in 1869 New York authorities ran a sting operation and arrested him for fraud. The prosecution's star witness was P. T. Barnum, who was himself photographed in a phony spirit image featuring Abraham Lincoln, but a parade of witnesses claimed they could not identify any trickery and Mumler was acquitted for lack of evidence.

"You'd think Mumler would have been scared straight and then everyone would now realize spirit photography was fake because of all the photographers explaining the process in the papers, but no," McCready said. Mumler continued his fraud photography work until his own demise, particularly exploiting widows, including Mary Todd Lincoln.

At the American Folklife Center, folklife specialist Meg Nicholas shared the 200-year-old legend of the Bell Witch, which begins in Tennessee with the ghost of Kate Batts. "We don't make a judgment as to whether the story is true or not, because honestly that's not the most important question. … It's why that story is being told in that particular area and all of the aspects around that story," Nicholas said. The legend appears in several collections, including a 1941 radio play produced through the Library's Radio Research Project.

Librarian Joanna Colclough discussed early print horror, including Eerie Comics by Avon Publishing in 1947, and EC Comics, whose horror titles replaced its crime series — "Crime Patrol" became "The Crypt of Terror" at issue No. 17 and was eventually retitled "Tales from the Crypt." EC ceased comic production in 1955 after the restrictive comics code limited horror content. "The EC horror comics had a really short run, but the output they were able to create was so impressive, and the lasting fanbase they had made it endure," Colclough said.

Archivist Andrea J. Briggs also processed an addition to the papers of Gutzon Borglum, best known for Mount Rushmore, including details of an 1903 commission to carve 30 gargoyles and grotesques for Princeton University's Class of 1879 Hall. Among his papers she found notes for an unfinished theatrical work featuring the gargoyles, with a main character named Sark. "I think he was working through some things as he was writing this play," Briggs said.