Journalists Casey Newton and Kevin Roose have launched Machine Gods, a new twice-weekly AI podcast produced in partnership with NPR, which they say will be built around an approach they call "AI realism."
The first episode covers misbehaving AI agents, the government's response, and a "sloppelganger" stealing Roose's book sales on Amazon. In the second episode, the hosts invite two recently fired OpenAI safety researchers to tell their side of the story and share what they worry about now that they are no longer at the company.
Writing in Platformer, the pair said the conversation around artificial intelligence has veered between two poles: skeptics such as Gary Marcus and Emily Bender, who argue large language models have critical flaws that will prevent them from reaching anything like superintelligence, and accelerationists, "represented loudest by the Andreessen Horowitz wing of the Republican Party," who believe the government should advance and proliferate the technology as quickly as possible.
The hosts said both camps reflect self-interest, and that in between them are "hundreds of millions of normal people who are just trying to understand what the week's AI news means for them." They noted public anxiety over job loss, chatbots that may prove harmful to children, deepfakes and slop taking over the web, and data centers appearing in backyards with minimal opportunity for public comment or oversight.
Newton and Roose said they will take seriously warnings from AI lab employees about catastrophic risks, including the rogue OpenAI agent swarm that attacked Hugging Face and subsequent industry warnings about approaching recursive self-improvement. But they said they have "always resisted being doomer journalists," arguing that journalism which only makes space for panic can leave people feeling hopeless.
"As journalists, it can feel like the incentives of our tribe are almost always to ask: what's bad about this?" they wrote. "But it is a particularly hollow and timid kind of journalism that finds itself unable to also ask: what could go right?"
The show will publish on Wednesday and Friday mornings from a new set designed by Skye Prey. The team includes executive producer Danush Parvaneh, senior producer Rachel Cohn, Jacob Blumberg and Sasha Ashall. The hosts said they have formed an LLC, signed an office lease and raised funding, with financial support from the Tarbell Center for AI Journalism, the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation and Emerson Collective.
They said funders "will have no influence on our editorial decisions," and that Machine Gods will come to public radio stations starting early next year as part of the NPR deal. The business will be built on ads, live events and occasional merch drops.
"We believe, first and foremost, that nothing is inevitable," they wrote. "There is no preordained dystopia waiting for us at the end of the AI rainbow, nor do we expect to see anything like the post-AGI utopia some boosters have promised."